Crunching the Numbers on an As-Is Cash Offer on your Bay Area Home from “We Buy Houses” Investors

If you’re considering selling your Bay Area home, you’ve likely seen advertisements from “We Buy Houses” companies offering a quick, as-is, all-cash sale. While these offers can seem appealing for homeowners looking to avoid the traditional selling process, it’s important to understand how much you’re likely to receive compared to listing your home on the open market.

How Much Will a “We Buy Houses” Company Offer?

Typically, these companies offer between 70% to 80% of your home’s fair market value. For example, if your Bay Area home has a potential market value of $1,000,000, you might receive offers ranging from $700,000 to $800,000. The lower offer accounts for the company’s need to resell the property for a profit after making repairs or improvements. The convenience of a fast sale without the need for repairs is one of the key reasons sellers choose this option, but it often comes at a steep discount.

Why Are Offers So Low?

“We Buy Houses” companies aim to make a profit by purchasing properties below market value, fixing them up, and selling them at a higher price. These investors factor in various costs, including:

1. Repair Costs: They’ll estimate what it will take to get the home market-ready. If your home requires significant repairs, expect a lower offer.
2. Holding Costs: While they own the home, they’ll incur property taxes, insurance, and loan interest, which they build into their offer price.
3. Resale Costs: They’ll pay agent commissions and closing costs when they resell, which further lowers their initial offer to you.
4. Profit Margin: On top of covering these costs, they need to make a profit, often aiming for at least a 10% to 20% return on investment.

For example, if your home has a $1,000,000 market value and needs $50,000 in repairs, the buyer might offer you $700,000 after subtracting repair and holding costs, plus a margin for their profit.

Comparing “We Buy Houses” Companies to iBuyers

It’s also worth noting that there’s a difference between traditional cash-for-home companies and iBuyers like Opendoor or iBuyer.com, which might pay closer to 90% of your home’s market value. These tech-driven companies usually target newer homes in better condition and charge a service fee, typically around 5%, for the convenience of a quick sale.

Sell your home in a weekend

The Benefits of Selling to a Cash Buyer

Despite the lower offer, selling to a “We Buy Houses” company can be a good option in certain situations:

• Speed: You can close in as little as 7 to 14 days.
• Convenience: No need to stage your home, hold open houses, or make repairs. These companies buy homes “as-is.”
• Certainty: Cash buyers don’t rely on financing, so there’s less risk of the deal falling through.

Selling to a cash buyer off market can make a lot of sense when your top priority is speed, certainty, and minimal disruption. The biggest advantage is simplicity: you usually skip the staging, open houses, constant cleaning, and throngs of strangers walking through your home. For some homeowners (especially those dealing with a life transition, health issue, tenants, or a packed schedule), that alone is worth a lot.

Cash buyers also tend to offer more predictable timelines. Without a loan approval, inspection contingencies, and a longer escrow, closings can be faster and smoother. And because many cash buyers purchase as-is, you may avoid repair negotiations, inspection punch lists, and the stress of scrambling to fix things on a deadline. If your home needs work, or you’d rather not invest time and money upfront, that can be a real relief.

There’s also a privacy factor. An off-market sale keeps your home off public real estate sites and can be a quieter way to transact—something many long-time homeowners appreciate.

The tradeoff, of course, is that convenience usually comes with a price discount, because the buyer is building in risk, repairs, carrying costs, and profit. But when the goal is to reduce hassle, avoid uncertainty, and move on quickly, an off-market cash sale can be a clean, practical option—especially if you’ve compared it against a fully exposed market sale and you’re comfortable with the difference.

What to Watch Out For

While many “We Buy Houses” companies are legitimate, it’s essential to do your due diligence. Look for companies with a solid reputation, and avoid those with hidden fees or unclear terms. Always compare multiple offers and consider getting a comparative market analysis (CMA) from a real estate agent to understand your home’s full value.

Ultimately, selling to a cash buyer may work well if speed and convenience are your top priorities, but for most homeowners in the Bay Area, listing your home on the open market will likely result in a higher net profit—even after accounting for agent commissions and selling costs.

Your Neighbor Sold their House too Cheap!

Who Would Sell Their Homes so Cheaply, and Why?

The people who take a “we buy houses” cash offer usually aren’t doing it because they think it’s the best financial deal — they’re doing it because they feel like it’s the easiest deal in a moment when life is heavy. The common thread is urgency, overwhelm, or a strong desire for privacy and simplicity. These companies typically price their offers at a steep discount (often roughly 70–80% of fair market value) in exchange for speed and convenience.

Here’s when I most often see it make sense from a homeowner’s perspective:

1. A time-sensitive crisis. Foreclosure pressure, a sudden medical event, or a need to relocate quickly for care can make “fast and certain” feel more valuable than “maximize every dollar.” These buyers can close fast (often in 7–14 days) and usually buy as-is, which removes a lot of steps.
2. Inherited property + long-distance logistics. When adult children inherit a home and live out of the area, the idea of coordinating cleanup, repairs, showings, and vendors can feel impossible. A cash sale becomes the “get this handled” button—especially if the house is dated, full of belongings, or hasn’t been maintained.
3. Burnout and decision fatigue. Some homeowners simply don’t have the bandwidth. They may be caring for a spouse, juggling work and aging parents, or emotionally tapped out. For them, the traditional process (prep, staging, open houses, negotiations) feels like one more full-time job.
4. Homes with major condition issues (real or perceived). If a property needs significant repairs—or the owner believes it does—cash offers can feel safer. The tradeoff is that investors bake in repairs, holding costs, resale costs, and profit margin, which is exactly why the number comes in low.

The key is this: selling this way is usually a convenience decision, not a wealth-building decision. If someone chooses it with eyes wide open—knowing the discount they’re accepting—then it can be a rational move. My job is making sure they understand the math and the alternatives before they sign anything.

Selling Quickly for Full Market Value…Even When a Home Needs Work

A lot of homeowners assume they have only two choices: either fix everything, gussy it up, and go “full retail”… or take a discounted off-market cash offer to avoid the hassle. But there’s a third option that’s surprisingly common in the Bay Area: list on the open market and sell as-is, doing little to no work, and still command full market value, and selling it very quickly, too.

Here’s why it works. When you list on-market, you’re exposing your home to all buyers, not just one investor who needs a huge margin due to holding costs, cost of capital, a good return on the investment, and as a cushion against considerable risk. However, sellers need to understand that broader demand (from the open market) is what drives price. Even if the house is dated, buyers will still compete if the home is priced correctly and the value is clear. Many buyers aren’t afraid of cosmetic updates—they’re planning to remodel anyway. What matters is that the home is positioned honestly, marketed well, and priced to create urgency.

“As-is” doesn’t mean “mystery box.” It means you’re not promising to fix things. You can still provide disclosures, reports, and transparency so buyers can make an informed decision. When buyers feel confident about what they’re getting, they’re more willing to come in strong.  Often times in the Bay Area, assuming a seller has done the inspections up-front and they have multiple competing offers, buyers will make offers no inspection contingencies.  This is actually superior to what you’ll find from an off-market cash buyer, who will in almost all circumstances require at least a 3 day inspection contingency (after which they may attempt to renegotiate and seek a still-lower price). 

And yes, you can still end up with a cash buyer even after listing publicly. In our market, plenty of well-capitalized buyers, with all-cash or large down payments, prefer the clean terms of a fast closing. If the home is priced right and demand is there, those buyers often show up within the first week. That’s how you get offers that can close in 14–21 days, with minimal drama.

The key is understanding the difference between selling as-is and selling off-market at a discount. You can keep the convenience and let the market do what it does best: deliver the maximum cash to you at closing.

Choose an Agent with the Right Strategy

If your goal is to sell on-market, as-is, with minimal prep and still walk away with maximum cash at closing, you really want an agent who’s done this specific kind of sale many times and who has the right strategy and marketing plan to achieve the result you need. “As-is” deals are won or lost in the details: how the home is positioned, how disclosures are handled, how offers are structured, and—most importantly—how the negotiation is run so that buyers are played off one another to squeeze out the best price and terms for the seller.

An experienced agent knows how to create urgency up front, attract the right buyer pool (including cash and large down-payment buyers), and then protect your net when the inevitable questions come in. In my experience, strong negotiation and smart offer strategy can be the difference between a clean deal and one that slowly gets chipped away—often by tens of thousands of dollars. The right agent doesn’t just “get it sold.” They help you keep more of what you earned.

For Best Results

Prime San Jose Real Estate and Homes for Sale