Four Biggest Painting Mistakes Made by Silicon Valley Home Sellers

If you’re thinking of selling your home  in the Bay Area, you’ve probably asked yourself if you should paint it – or paint part of it.  Of course, not every home needs to be painted before you put a home up for sale.  But in some cases, even freshly painted homes could benefit from repainting.

There’s a lot to know about painting before you sell your home in the Bay Area, but it’s good to start with the biggest mistakes first, to get those out of the way.  So here they go:

Mistake #1: Don’t do patchy touch-ups

Patchy touch-ups can make walls look worse, as fresh paint rarely blends perfectly with older, faded surfaces. Even using the same can of paint, differences in texture, light exposure, and application methods can make the touch-up spots stand out. Instead of dabbing over small areas, repaint the entire wall for a smooth, seamless look that feels fresh and well-maintained. If repainting isn’t an option, try cleaning scuffs with a Magic Eraser or lightly feathering the new paint outward with a roller to blend it in better. A clean, uniform wall gives the impression of a well-cared-for home, making it more appealing to buyers.

Mistake #2: Don’t paint over natural wood cabinets

Painting over natural wood cabinets can often do more harm than good, especially if the wood has a classic or high-quality finish. Instead of masking their natural beauty with paint, a better approach is to clean and restore them to enhance their original charm. Using a wood cleaner or a product like Murphy’s Oil Soap can help remove built-up grime and bring out the richness of the wood grain. If the cabinets appear dull or worn, applying a wood conditioner or a light stain can revitalize their appearance without completely altering their character.

Many buyers appreciate the warmth and timeless appeal of natural wood, and painted cabinets can sometimes signal an attempt to cover up damage rather than preserve the home’s original craftsmanship. Before deciding to paint, consider how the existing wood tones complement the space, as well-maintained natural wood cabinets can be a selling point, especially in kitchens with traditional or rustic aesthetics.

Mistake #3: Going too bold with the color

Choosing bold or overly trendy paint colors may seem like a great way to add personality to a home, but it can actually work against you when trying to sell. While vibrant hues and unique shades might reflect personal style, they often don’t have universal appeal and can make it harder for buyers to envision themselves in the space. Instead, opting for neutral tones like soft whites, warm beiges, or light grays creates a blank canvas that complements a variety of décor styles and allows potential buyers to see the home’s full potential.

Neutrals also enhance natural light, making rooms feel more open, clean, and inviting. Trendy colors can quickly go out of style, and what feels modern today might feel outdated in just a few years. By sticking with classic, neutral shades, you ensure that your home remains attractive to the widest audience, increasing its chances of selling quickly and for the best possible price.

Mistake #4: Painting when you don’t really need to

Before automatically deciding to repaint your home before selling, take a step back and assess whether it’s truly necessary. If your walls are already in good condition with a neutral, fresh coat of paint, spending time and money on repainting may not add significant value. Many sellers assume a fresh coat is always needed, but in reality, buyers are more concerned with the overall condition and feel of the home rather than whether the walls were painted right before listing.

If the existing paint is still clean, modern, and free from scuffs or bold colors that might turn off buyers, it may be best to leave it as is and focus your efforts on other areas that could make a bigger impact, such as decluttering, deep cleaning, or improving curb appeal. However, if the paint is showing signs of wear—fading, stains, or outdated shades—then a fresh coat in a neutral tone can be a worthwhile investment. The key is to evaluate your home’s current state and only repaint if it will genuinely enhance its marketability.

Timing is Everything in Life

Should Selling and Painting go Hand in Hand?

If you’re getting ready to sell your home, chances are you’ve thought about ways to make it more appealing to buyers. One of the most common recommendations from real estate professionals is to repaint your home before listing it.

The logic behind this advice is simple—painting is often seen as one of the easiest, most cost-effective ways to freshen up a home and increase its value. But is that always true? Is painting really necessary in every case? The answer depends on several factors.

Before you rush out to buy gallons of paint, let’s take a deeper look at whether repainting is worth it, what colors sell the best, and what mistakes you should avoid when it comes to paint choices in today’s real estate market.

When Should You Repaint Before Selling

Painting isn’t always necessary, but in certain cases, it can make a big difference. Here’s when repainting makes sense:

• ✅ Your current paint colors are too bold or outdated. If you have bright red walls, deep purple ceilings, or an outdated Tuscan color palette, repainting is a must. Buyers want a home that feels modern, clean, and neutral, and bold color choices can be a turnoff.
• ✅ Your walls are scuffed, stained, or chipped. Even if your paint color is neutral, if the walls look worn, dirty, or damaged, it signals neglect. A fresh coat of paint can make an older home feel brand new.
• ✅ Your home hasn’t been painted in years. Paint fades over time, and trends change. If it’s been more than five years since your last paint job, it’s worth considering a refresh to make the home look more updated.
• ✅ Your rooms feel dark and cramped. Light colors can make a home feel larger, brighter, and more inviting. If you have dark walls that make rooms feel smaller, a new coat of off-white or light beige paint can completely transform the space.
• ✅ Your home has an inconsistent color scheme. If every room in your house is a different color, repainting can create a cohesive, unified look that appeals to buyers.

When Can You Skip Repainting?

Repainting isn’t always necessary, and there are situations where it won’t provide a return on investment. Here’s when you can likely skip it:

• ❌ Your paint is already neutral and in great condition. If you recently painted your home in a buyer-friendly color and it still looks fresh, you probably don’t need to repaint.
• ❌ Your home is in a super-hot market. If homes in your area are selling quickly with multiple offers, buyers might overlook minor paint imperfections.
• ❌ The buyer will likely renovate. If your home is older and needs significant updates, buyers might plan to remodel the entire space anyway—including the walls. In that case, repainting won’t add much value.

What Paint Colors Do Buyers Love in 2025?

If you decide to repaint before selling your home, selecting the right color is just as crucial as the decision to paint in the first place. The goal is to create a space that feels fresh, inviting, and universally appealing to buyers. In 2025, neutral tones continue to dominate the real estate market, as they provide a blank canvas that allows potential buyers to envision their own style within the home.

Soft whites, warm off-whites, and light “greige” tones are among the most popular choices, offering a modern yet timeless feel that complements a variety of design aesthetics. Subtle earth tones, like warm beiges with a hint of taupe, are also gaining traction, as they bring a cozy and welcoming ambiance without feeling outdated.

While gray was a staple for years, cooler shades are losing favor in comparison to warmer, natural hues that create a more inviting atmosphere. A well-chosen neutral shade not only enhances the home’s overall appeal but also helps it photograph better for online listings, making it a smart investment for sellers looking to attract the widest pool of buyers.

Change Happens

Best Paint Colors for Selling a Home in 2025

The safest and most timeless choice is, of course white:  always has been, and always will be. White never goes out of style (although the quantity might). White walls make a space feel clean, fresh, and open, and they work with any décor style. However, not all whites are the same! Popular options include:

• Swiss Coffee (Behr) – A warm, creamy white
• Simply White (Benjamin Moore) – A soft, bright white
• Pure White (Sherwin-Williams) – A crisp, clean white with a subtle warmth

 Off-White & Greige (Gray + Beige) – If stark white feels too sterile, “greige” is the perfect balance of warm and cool tones. Great options:

• Repose Gray (Sherwin-Williams) – A soft, warm gray
• Agreeable Gray (Sherwin-Williams) – A crowd-pleasing neutral
• Classic Gray (Benjamin Moore) – A subtle, barely-there warm gray

Light Beige & Earth Tones – Earth tones are making a comeback, offering warmth and coziness without feeling too dark. Look for:

• Accessible Beige (Sherwin-Williams) – A light, sandy beige
• Edgecomb Gray (Benjamin Moore) – A warm greige that works well with wood tones

Colors to Avoid When Selling Your Home

When preparing to sell your home, it’s essential to choose paint colors that appeal to the widest audience, which means avoiding overly bold, dark, or outdated shades. Bright and unconventional colors like red, purple, or orange can be too specific, making it difficult for buyers to envision their own furniture and decor in the space. Dark colors such as navy, forest green, or deep brown can make rooms feel smaller, heavier, and less inviting, which is the opposite of what buyers typically look for.

Additionally, outdated Tuscan tones like gold, mustard, and deep terracotta can make a home feel stuck in a past era, signaling to buyers that the space may need updates. A fresh, neutral palette will create a clean, modern look that enhances the home’s overall appeal and helps potential buyers see themselves living there.

Key takeaways

• Bright or unconventional colors (reds, purples, oranges) – Too specific and hard for buyers to picture their own furniture in.
• Dark colors (navy, forest green, deep brown) – These can make a space feel small and heavy.
• Outdated Tuscan tones (gold, mustard, deep terracotta) – These can date a home and make it feel stuck in another era.

How to Choose the Right Paint for Your Home

Before grabbing a paintbrush, take a step back and evaluate your home’s existing features. The right color will depend on:

• 🏡 Your Kitchen Cabinets – If you have dark oak or cherry wood cabinets, a cool gray might clash. Instead, choose a warm white or greige.
• 🛋️ Your Flooring – Make sure your wall color complements your flooring. If you have warm-toned wood, avoid cool grays that will contrast too harshly.
• 🖼️ Recently Sold Homes in Your Area – Look at homes that sold quickly and for a high price. What colors did they use? This is often a great indicator of what works in your market.
• 💡 Lighting in Your Home – Always test paint swatches in natural light! The color that looks great in a showroom might look completely different on your walls.

Pro Painting Tips for a High-Quality Look

If you’re investing time and money into painting, make sure you do it right. Buyers notice the details!

• Use Peel-and-Stick Samples – This is an easy way to test paint colors on your walls without committing.
• Choose Eggshell or Satin Finish for Walls – These finishes hide imperfections better than flat paint and are easier to clean.
• Use Semi-Gloss for Trim and Doors – This makes trim pop and adds a polished look.
• Don’t Forget Ceilings! – A fresh white ceiling can make a room feel brighter and cleaner.
• Hire a Pro if Needed – A bad paint job is worse than no paint job. If you’re not confident in your painting skills, it’s worth hiring a professional.

Final Thoughts: Should You Repaint Before Selling?

A fresh coat of paint can completely transform your home’s appearance and attract more buyers, but it’s not always necessary.

If your home’s current paint is neutral and in good condition, you might be better off saving your time and money. However, if your walls are bold, outdated, or worn, investing in a new paint job can help your home sell faster and for more money.

The key? Keep it neutral, fresh, and inviting. Buyers want a home that feels move-in ready—not a project they’ll have to repaint before moving in.

Thinking of selling your home soon? A fresh coat of paint might be just what the doctor ordered.

Time to talk to a REALTOR?

Amazing Mountain View Homes for Sale