How Does Deferred Maintenance Impact Sale Price?

One question I get over and over is, “How Does Deferred Maintenance Impact Sale Price?” for homes in the Bay Area. This is an issue that often comes up along the way regardless of if you are buying or selling a home.  In this article, though, I’ll be looking at it primarily from the perspective of the seller.

One of the primary issues that plague both buyers and sellers is deferred maintenance. Deferred maintenance in real estate refers to the practice of delaying or waiting on doing maintenance tasks around your home. If you took an objective look around your home, you’d probably see a few examples of deferred maintenance, like a rotting trim around the garage door, worn-out carpet, flaking paint, a double-paned window that is fogged due to a failed seal, or something else that you’ve continued to put off. We all have those items that just never got checked off the to-do list.

Make no mistake about it, you can sell any home in any condition in the Bay Area. It really doesn’t matter what kind of condition a home is in; you can sell it. In fact, you can sell a property that has been completely destroyed by fire and has nothing left standing other than a back wall. Property in the greater San Francisco Bay area is in such high demand that someone will make an offer on the property. However, there are some things that you will need to consider before you put your property on the market, such as what I call “asset preservation” and preventive maintenance.

What if you want to sell your home for the same price you could if no repairs were needed…and but without fixing any of that deferred maintenance?

How to Sell a Home with Deferred Maintenance

One of the most important factors that you will need to consider before selling your home that you have put off the maintenance on is that pricing matters. Obviously, pricing matters regardless of the condition of your home. You’re not going to sell a home that’s worth $1,200,000 for $1.8 million, regardless of how much deferred maintenance or capital expenditures you’ve done on the property. However, when you’ve put off some maintenance tasks around your home, you’ll need to price it accordingly.

Let’s assume that you have a 2,000 square-foot home in an area where homes routinely sell for around $800 per square foot. A quick glance at the numbers means that you’re going to list your home for around $1,600,000. However, your home needs some paint, new carpet, the windows need to be replaced, and you have a few other deferred maintenance tasks that need to be addressed (clogged rain gutters, rusted flashing, a leaky sink faucet – the potential list is long!).

For Best Results

If you were to get an estimate on the cost to overhaul a property, you may find that it’s going to cost around $50 per square foot to do a laundry-list of work including some rot repair, painting, maybe some flooring, window replacement, etc. Since you have a 2,000 square foot home, that means that you are looking at around $100,000 in deferred maintenance costs. Now, it’s easy to assume that you’ll just knock off $100,000, sell your home, and someone will offer you $1,500,000 before doing the repairs themselves with the $100,000 that they saved. But that’s simply not how it works.

It is really important that you accurately set the market price to reflect the cost of repair – and then some. Buyers will not purchase a home that needs $100,000 worth of deferred maintenance for $100,000 less than you believe it would be worth, had those maintenance items been addressed. There are several reasons for that. First of all, while fixer uppers have become popular in reality TV shows, many people who are buying homes, especially homes in an area like the Bay Area, simply do not want fixer uppers. Since home prices are so high, and the people who live in the area are professionals, they want a home that they consider move in ready. Obviously, they’re often willing to make a few upgrades to the home that makes it more of their style, but most buyers in Silicon Valley don’t want to buy a home that they feel will need considerable work before they move in.

Additionally, there is the fear that the home may need more than $100,000 worth of deferred maintenance work. While you may have gotten an estimate on the things that you believe need to be done to the home, what if once the buyer begins working on the house, they discover that actually there’s a lot of rot behind the stucco because that wall was leaking, and there’s also a bunch of mold in the walls that will require remediation?

The buyer just doesn’t know.  They can’t know.  So they are going to need to factor in a buffer on the repair cost, knowing that it could well be higher than what you or they expect.

Perhaps most importantly, there is a question about where the buyer is going to get the additional budget to repair the property. Let’s assume that your $100,000 estimate meets all the buyer’s concerns for the home condition. Where are they going to come up with $100,000 to perform those deferred maintenance repairs? Remember, the buyer is out a lot of cash in this transaction. By the time they borrow enough money to buy the house, use their own funds as a down payment, pay closing costs, the price of moving, and any other number of fees associated with buying a new home, they may not have access to an extra $100,000 to pay for maintenance that you have deferred.

Which means that the buyer pool for your property is somewhat smaller, and will be limited to just those buyers who have that additional cash to do a lot of work after closing.  And the fact that the buyer pool is smaller means…the price will have to be adequately lowered to address that fact.

How to Price a Home with Deferred Maintenance

I always let my seller clients know that they need to price the home below what they would consider to be as-is-market value. For the reasons that we just discussed above, a buyer who views your property and sees $100,000 in needed deferred maintenance costs simply isn’t going to offer you the “after repaired” price of your home, minus $100,000. They’re going to offer less.  But how much less?  What’s the formula?

Well, there isn’t a perfect, constant mathematical formula. However, I generally encourage my buyers to price their home with a price that takes off at least 150% of the price of repairs. That means that you would list your hypothetical $1,600,000 home for no more than $1,450,000.

That’s not because your home is a “dump.” Instead, it’s because we have to find a way to create a sense of value in the property. When a buyer believes that they can get a home that’s worth $1,6000,000 for $1,450,000, even if it needs some deferred maintenance work, they’re more apt to make a competitive offer on the property.

Yes, you can absolutely sell a home in the Bay Area that has some deferred maintenance issue, which is a very common in Silicon Valley due to the age of most housing stock. Additionally, there are benefits of pricing things lower. Not only does the buyer perceive a greater value, but you may be able to generate even more interest in your property. Remember, the three biggest factors in real estate are location, location, and location. If you competitively price your home, deferred maintenance and all, in a good neighborhood, the buyers will most certainly come pouring in.

Selling For the As-Repaired Price in As-Is Condition

But what if you want to have your cake and eat it too?  What if you want to sell your “bit of a fixer-upper” home for the move-in ready price?  Can it be done?

It’s been known to happen.  And that’s because there are so many factors that go into the final sale price.  Like location, lot size, square footage, floor plan, landscaping, the list goes on.

The key to getting the highest price possible – on-par with those “move-in ready” homes – is so set the price low enough that you get a fierce bidding war going.  When you have a truly epic bidding war, you find every possible buyer for your property, who will all find different things they value in the property.  Some of them won’t mind the deferred maintenance, because almost regardless of the condition of they home, they’re pretty much planning on blowing most of it, anyway?  What if there’s a well-heeled buyer out there who actually likes orange shag carpet and avocado green counter tile?

The best chance you have for selling your home which “needs a little work” for the same price as those more-polished homes is to just set the price at the point where you get a frenzy going, and have buyers compete for the privilege of buying your home.  You will be surprised how much more you might get for it, if you use an aggressive pricing strategy.

It turns out, I specialize in just these kind of homes and just this kind of strategy.  If you’d like to talk to someone who knows how to get you the highest price possible on homes that need some work, please contact me today.

Time to talk to a REALTOR?

Check out this article next

Making a Lowball Offer on a Bay Area Home

Making a Lowball Offer on a Bay Area Home

Today we’re going to talk about a topic that isn’t exactly popular. In fact, it’s not even a topic that I’ve discussed recently in my…

Read Article
About the Author
Seb Frey helps long-time Bay Area homeowners make their next move easily the next one yet. If you're looking for a minimum of hassle, maximum net cash on sale, and certain results, contact Seb today.